Mariah Carey sued again by same person over 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'
This lawsuit comes a year after Vince Vance made similar allegations.
Mariah Carey's iconic holiday hit, "All I Want for Christmas Is You," is the subject of a legal dispute once again. Songwriter Vince Vance, whose real name is Andy Stone, has filed a lawsuit in a Los Angeles federal court, alleging that Carey's 1994 Christmas classic infringes on the copyrights of his 1989 song of the same name. This lawsuit comes a year after Vance made similar allegations and brings some intriguing arguments to the forefront.
In his new complaint, Vance asserts that Carey's hit song is not an original creation. He accuses Carey of fabricating the story of how she came up with the song and claims that her co-writer, Walter Afanasieff, disputes this account. Vance's legal team suggests that Carey has presented the song as her own, which raises questions about the authenticity of her creative process.
What makes this legal battle particularly noteworthy is the consistent chart-topping success of Mariah Carey's "All I Want for Christmas Is You." The song has claimed the top spot on the Billboard Hot 100 during each of the past four holiday seasons, becoming a beloved staple of the holiday season.
The lawsuit also highlights the prior success of Vance's own version of "All I Want for Christmas Is You," recorded by Vince Vance and the Valiants in 1989. It was played extensively during the 1993 holiday season, a year before Carey released her more famous rendition under the same title. Vance's song achieved recognition as a "country music hit," reaching No. 31 on Billboard's Hot Country Songs chart and No. 23 on the Hot 100 Airplay chart.
Furthermore, Vance's legal team argues that there are notable similarities between the two songs. They claim that the phrase "all I want for Christmas is you" was distinctive in the context of 1988 and that the specific chord progression in the melody, combined with the verbatim hook, amounts to a "greater than 50% clone" of Vance's original work.
&im=FitAndFill=(700,400))
National Handloom Day 2026: From Alia Bhatt to Samantha Ruth Prabhu; Actresses who celebrated India's textile heritage as brides
)
The Royals enter the Doctor Who universe: King Charles and Queen Camilla beam into Commonwealth Games in TARDIS
)
Unitree Robotics targets $9 billion valuation in landmark IPO backed by DeepSeek and Tencent
)
India names 27 sites in Arunachal Pradesh
)
Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata OTT: When will Kangana Ranaut's film stream online?
&im=FitAndFill=(700,400))
How many soldiers operate one S-400 battery?
)
Shakib Al Hasan ready to return to Bangladesh—under one condition
)
‘Fake news’: MEA rejects report claiming India sought defence pact with Israel after Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Turkey deal
)
Rockstar to unveil GTA 6 extended look ahead of November launch
)
Russia forms Ukrainian Volunteer Spetsnaz Brigade to fight Ukraine
)
Drug-resistant fungus that hides in hair and enters bloodstream reported in 23 US states
)
Technology transfer deal boosts India's defence manufacturing ambitions
)
Border row erupts in Europe after Ceuta crossings, Spain imposes border controls on Italy
)
Morale plummets on USS Abraham Lincoln: Are US sailors reaching a breaking point? | GRAVITAS
)
'Security can't be bought with Pakistan, Turkey deal': Iran tells Saudi Arabia
)
Baba Vanga's 2026 prophecy: 2 predictions 'already came true', 3 terrifying ones remain. Details inside
)
Colombia’s new president Abelardo de la Espriella vows to ‘defeat narco-terrorists’, signals hardline shift
&im=FitAndFill=(700,400))
New Friday OTT releases (August 7, 2026): Operation Safed Sagar, Vadhandhi, Main Vaapis Aaunga- 6 movies and TV shows on Netflix, Prime Video and more
)
Squadron Leader Bhawana Kanth scripts history as Indian Air Force gets its first woman ‘Top Gun’ pilot
)
RSS says Gen Z protests reflect genuine distress
)
Trump says Iranian school bombing photos could be AI-generated - 'I don’t think...'
)
IAF officer held for sharing sensitive information in 'honey trap' case, booked under Official Secrets Act
)
Stray Kids under scrutiny? Fans react to Grammy submission silence after BTS boycott
&im=FitAndFill=(700,400))
Why the Su-30MKI doesn't need external fuel tanks to fly vast distances
)
Jugal Hansraj reunites with Shekhar Kapur after 40 years for Masoom: The Next Generation
)
New speed limits, automatic challans: Big traffic change coming to Delhi-Meerut Expressway. All you need to know
)
India officially names 27 places in Arunachal to counter China's renaming claims
)
Trump calls White House ballroom ruling a 'national disgrace' as court says Congress approval needed
)
US sanctions Iran’s crypto network after Strait of Hormuz attacks, offers $15m bounty for intel on IRGC finance
&im=FitAndFill=(700,400))
Why the Su-30MKI is one of the heaviest fighters ever built
)
Uttarakhand young innovator builds India's own flying vehicle, conducts first test flight: WATCH
)
Chilling video shows students take cover as teen opens fire at Thai school
)
Reese Witherspoon's father hospitalised after poolside incident in Nashville: Report
The lawsuit also mentions the 2003 Christmas movie Love Actually, in which Mariah Carey's song is featured. This reference underscores the song's significance in the holiday canon and hints at the potential impact of its inclusion in a popular film.