Experts say Trump has little power to restart US economy

Hours after the US President Donald Trump claimed that it was his decision when to reopen the US economy, which has been largely shut down to slow the spread of the novel coronavirus, legal experts say a US president has quite limited power to order citizens back to their places of employment, or cities to reopen government buildings, transportation, or local businesses. Here is why.

What does the Constitution say about who makes decisions about public welfare?

Add WION as a Preferred Source

The United States is a federalist system, meaning power is shared between national and state governments.

Under the 10th Amendment of the USConstitution, state governments have the power to police citizens and regulate public welfare. In the country's early years, it was up to state and local authorities to lead the response to the yellow fever epidemic, not the federal government.

Reflecting these principles, "disaster response and aid are typically state-led and federally supported," said Steve Bunnell, the former top lawyer at the USDepartment of Homeland Security (DHS) and a partner at O'Melveny & Myers.

This bottom-up, rather than top-down, approach to disaster relief makes sense from a policy perspective, said John Cohen, a former DHS official who teaches at Georgetown University.

"Usually, state and local officials on the ground have the best understanding of the issues affecting people in their states," Reuters report quoting Cohen stated.

Can a US president override state-mandated "shelter in place" orders?

No. The Trump administration can issue nationwide guidance, but it would be unconstitutional for the president to override stay-at-home orders from governors, said Robert Chesney, a professor of national security law at the University of Texas. Mayors or county commissioners are on the same footing as governors, he said.

"This is Federalism 101: The president can advocate his heart’s content, but he can’t commandeer the state governments to make them change their policies," Chesney said.

"He has no such inherent authority, nor is there any federal statute that purports to give him such authority."

(With inputs from Reuters)