Emraan Hashmi on #MeToo allegations against director Soumik Sen: Can't play judge and decide on verdict

WION Web Team
New Delhi, Delhi, IndiaUpdated: Jan 15, 2019, 03:19 PM IST
main img
Photograph:(WION Web Team)

Story highlights

'Why Cheat India' director Soumik Sen's name has not been taken out of the film's credit role despite multiple women accusing Sen of sexual misconduct. 

As #MeToo movement gained momentum in India, several prominent names from the film industry were called out for sexual misconduct. Directors Vikas Bahl, Sajid Khan and actor Nana Patekar were asked to step down from their ongoing projects as they were accussed by women of sexual harassment. But unlike these men, producer Emraan Hashmi decided not to remove director Soumi Sen's name from 'Why Cheat India' credit role. 

Hashmi who serves as a co-producer and the lead in the film stated that he did not want to take a 'high-handed' approach to oust someone from a film without being assured of the credibility of the accusations. 

"There should be a due process. I can't have this high-handed authority on a set and say 'You're out of my film and three women have accused you of this'. I don't know the validity of the accusations. 

"I've not spoken to the women personally. They have not gone to the judicial system and had the due process. The producers spoke to him (Sen) and he excused himself from the promotions," Emraan told a news agency. 

Regarding claims against Sen, the actor said when the news broke, the film's team investigated the matter to check if any inappropriate behaviour took place on the sets but nothing of the kind was reported. 

"The next question to be asked was the authenticity of the allegations. When you have names thrown on social media, it could be malicious. Not that I am defending Soumik, but there's no due process here, no proof. 

"Sometimes there could be malicious intent. We kept it to the point that he has excused himself from the film promotions. It's a step where we probably have done our bit," he added. 

The actor believes the question is what happens after someone takes a name on social media with regards to sexual misconduct. 

"What do we do? Just chuck the person out of a company or have an investigation, a due process in this? Unfortunately, the women didn't go to the judicial system or the police."

When pointed out that it could be because the legal process is both, exhausting and intimidating, Emraan agreed, adding "Sometimes women don't have proof but that doesn't mean it didn't happen. The entire thing is so grey, what are the steps to be taken?" 

"We have not denied those allegations... If Soumik has done something, he should be taken to task. I can't play judge and decide on a verdict. The courts have to draw out a process, which has not been done so far. Twitter cannot be a courtroom," he said.

Filmmaker Rajkumar Hirani was named in the #MeToo by an anonymous woman, who worked as "an assistant" on 'Sanju'. The complainant accused the director of sexually abusing on more than one account between March and September 2018.

When asked if someone as powerful as Hirani is being named in the #MeToo, will it change industry dynamics, the actor said he cannot "speak about this case".
Emraan, however, adds that the #MeToo movement has his full support. 

"It's great that women are coming out and putting their stories forward but we have to have some process in place. Now that the allegations are out and men are forewarned that 'don't do this', we need to, like how I did with my company, set the laws the government has placed about sexual harassment.

"It's not a gender thing. It's a power thing. A woman in a position of power can harass a male colleague. The power dynamics are very lopsided and can swing both ways," he said.

'Why Cheat India' is scheduled to release this Friday. 

(With inputs from PTI)