Cattle sale ban: Indian meat traders plan legal action, Kerala CM to write to PM Modi
Butchers from the Qureshi community gather outside meat shops ordered to close, following regulations imposed by newly elected Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath in Lucknow on April 4. Photograph: (Reuters)
Indian meat traders plan to take the government to court over new rules banning the trading of cattle including buffalo for slaughter, calling it a move by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's administration to hurt the business run mainly by Muslims.
The environment ministry said this week that animal markets will only be able to trade in cattle meant for agricultural purposes, the biggest blow yet for meat suppliers facing several reverses under Modi's three-year old Hindu nationalist government.
The slaughter of cows, considered holy in Hinduism, is banned in most Indian states and laws on the issue have become more stringent over the past few years. Muslims, who make up 14 per cent of India's 1.3 billion people, dominate the Indian meat industry.
India is the biggest seller of buffalo meat in the world, with exports of more than $4 billion a year to countries such as Vietnam, Malaysia and Egypt.
But that could change following the government's May 23 notification regarding changes to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, made public on Friday. It requires owners to declare that cattle have not "been brought to market for sale for slaughter" and for market committees to verify that the buyer is an "agriculturist by seeing the relevant revenue document".
The new rules define cattle as bulls, cows, buffalo, steers, heifers, calves and camels.
"The business is dead," said Aqil Qureshi, president of the Delhi Buffalo Traders' Welfare Association who runs a slaughterhouse outside the city and sells hides to leather companies. "We will take legal help, we will hit the streets. Who does not fight for their livelihood?"
The environment ministry said in a statement on Saturday that the regulation was to protect "animals from cruelty and not to regulate the existing trade in cattle for slaughter houses". Animals for slaughter will have to be bought from farmers directly, it said.
Abdul Faheem Qureshi, a lawyer in Hyderabad and head of the All India Jamiatul Quresh Action Committee, said direct buying was "not always practical" and that he was drafting a court appeal after meeting with many of his "shocked" trader clients.
Al Faheem Meatex, an exporter in Uttar Pradesh, said buying buffalo directly from farmers was likely to raise costs, given stringent norms on cattle transportation.
"It will raise costs for us but what else can we do?" the company said. "We will see if we can get some relief from the court."
Qureshi said the new law would only embolden cow vigilantism groups. Muslims have been assaulted by Hindu hardliners over the past few years on suspicion of eating beef or illegally transporting cattle.
GVL Narasimha Rao, a spokesman for Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party, had no immediate comment. Government spokesman Frank Noronha did not respond to requests for comment.
Protests in South India
People in India's southern Coimbatore city took to the streets today (May 27) against the decision on banning sale of cattle for slaughter.
Protesters raised slogans and burnt an effigy of Modi before being detained by police.
Under the new rules, prior to trade, both seller and buyer will be required to produce an identity proof and farmland ownership documents.
Post the purchase, a trader must make five copies of proof of sale and submit three at the local revenue office, the local veterinary doctor in the district of the buyer and animal market committee respectively, apart from one each for seller and himself.
India's southern Kerala state, where cow slaughter is legal, too objected to the notification.
Questioning the purpose of the federal government's move, Kerala finance minister, Thomas Isaac, said it was a big blow to the agrarian economy.
Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan will reportedly write to PM Modi to register the state's protest.
Meanwhile, India's environment minister, Dr. Harsh Vardhan, said the new rules sought to ensure that animal markets and fairs are not used for trading cattle for slaughter.