Police officers and Special Task Force soldiers stand beside dead bodies of the suspected members of the banned Students Islamic Movement of India. Photograph: (Reuters)
Eyewitness say the 8 men had no chance of escape, 'at least some of them could... have been forced to surrender'
A report in The Hindu newspaper has said that the encounter with police in which eight escapees from India's Bhopal central jail were killed was witnessed by “scores of people from about a dozen villages”, and that the escapees – who are accused, among other things, of being members of the banned Students' Islamic Movement of India or SIMI – did not have weapons on them.
When the story first broke – the men had “escaped” from jail early on Monday morning; they were dead a few hours later – the police had said the men were armed with four country-made pistols and two knives. (There were conflicting versions then too – the state home minister had said that the men had fashioned knives out of prison-issued utensils, while the chief of the state's anti-terror squad had said that the men were not armed.)
The newspaper report says: “Scores of people from about a dozen villages witnessed the alleged encounter between the police and the (alleged) SIMI undertrials who 'escaped' from Bhopal central jail early on Monday morning, but eyewitnesses The Hindu spoke to did not recall 'seeing' the suspects use firearms against police.”
The report goes on to say that the “eyewitnesses are sure the suspects threw stones at the police and the public, chanted slogans and challenged them to attack. They also do not recollect spotting any pistols next to the bodies of the dead men, although many of them claimed that a knife-kind of object was lying near one of the slain persons.”
The report adds: “The eight SIMI men had no escape route when the police surrounded them.”
In the report, Ram Kumar Soni, a security guard at a construction site in Acharpura village, which the newspaper says is close to the site of the encounter, tells The Hindu that he was one of the first to reach the site of the encounter and that the “policemen began the firing”.
The Hindu also quotes Pappu Meena, a farmer the newspaper says lives in a hut close to the 'encounter site'. “... he too neither saw the SIMI suspects open fire nor found any pistols next to their bodies”, the report says.
“I saw some of those men waving their hands while others were pelting stones. After that, the police asked us to keep away citing our safety,” Meena tells The Hindu.
Manoj Meena, who the newspaper says is a resident of Manikhedi Kot, tells the newspaper that as he and the police approached the outcrop of rocks the escapees were stranded on, the escapees attacked them with stones. “Asking us to lie down, police began firing in the air. But there was no gunfire from the other side,” he told The Hindu.
The report adds: “Most of the locals acknowledged that the SIMI suspects had no escape options. The other side of the rocks they were standing on overlooks a 50-feet drop.”
“At least some of them could certainly have been forced to surrender,” Ram Kumar Soni told The Hindu.